3 years ago
331
The Board of Supervisors connected Tuesday, Sept. 29, directed the Los Angeles County Coroner’s Office to usage its subpoena powers to execute inquests into 3 deputy-involved deaths. The determination outraged Sheriff Alex Villanueva, who called the determination a nonstop “political attack” connected his department.
Supervisors Holly Mitchell and Hilda Solis co-authored the question recommending the inquests into the shooting deaths of 47-year-old Dana “Malik” Young Jr., 41-year-old Samuel Herrera Jr. and 29-year-old Dijon Kizzee, each changeable and killed by deputies past year.
Under the board’s action, the Sheriff’s Department would either person to stock investigatory accusation with the main aesculapian examiner, oregon supply an mentation arsenic to wherefore specified sharing was not needed.
Citing authorities accountability legislation, supervisors accidental an inquest provides a ineligible “tool” by which an “independent” probe that could springiness answers to families that requested much answers.
“There needs to be, astatine the precise least, a reappraisal of the grounds successful these cases, which tin beryllium provided via an inquest,” said Mitchell.
“We bash not cognize what happened during the people of these investigations and however they were conducted,” Mitchell added. “The Office of Inspector General was not allowed to show each measurement … and truthful concerns stay astir their integrity, fixed the deficiency of true, comprehensive, autarkic oversight.”
The imaginable of inquests brought an contiguous rebuke from Villanueva, who said the board’s request was a deliberate broadside against him and his department, who person been astatine likelihood with supervisors done overmuch of his tenure.
“I request to halt you close there,” Villanueva said during a nationalist remark slot. “The lone entity that is trying to merchantability the thought to the nationalist that we are not transparent, that we don’t clasp radical accountable, is you, the Board of Supervisors.”
Villanueva accused the committee of “having a unusual thought of what justness involves.” He said his section has shared accusation connected each 3 cases with the county’s Office of Inspector General.
“All 3 of those cases person already been delivered to the Justice System Integrity Division of the D.A.’s Office successful its entirety,” helium said. “The inspector wide has each azygous lawsuit successful its entirety,” helium said, accusing the committee of “deliberately misleading the public.”
Mitchell countered: “I judge our residents merit much than alternatively juvenile name-calling.” Solis and different committee members said they wished they didn’t person to enactment astir the sheriff to get the accusation they needed.
Supervisor Kathryn Barger said she believes the sheriff undermined his ain section by coating a representation that the committee is anti-law enforcement.
“We’re not,” Barger said. “We privation accountability (in each departments). Accountability is captious successful nationalist trust.”
The District Attorney’s Office has each 3 cases nether reappraisal to find whether the shootings were a lawful usage of force, according to a DA’s spokesman.
Some members of the Civilian Oversight Commission, a watchdog radical charged with overseeing the sheriff’s department, person pressed for inquests successful each fatal lawman shootings.
The 3 cases that propelled the board’s order:
— Dana “Malik” Young Jr.: Young was changeable connected Oct. 15, 2020, aft a conveyance pursuit that ended with Young crashing his car into a gross astatine Woodcrest Elementary School, according to instrumentality enforcement and region coroner’s records.
According to the department, successful the ft pursuit that followed, Young ran toward responding deputies, who said Young “raised a achromatic entity successful his close hand.” The lawman fired 8 rounds astatine Young astatine little than six feet away. The achromatic entity was determined to beryllium a black, COVID-19-style mask.
Supporters of Young person requested much accusation astir the probe and demanded that the section occurrence the deputy. They besides decried that Young’s assemblage was near astatine the country for respective hours.
The Sheriff’s Department said Young had kidnapped a pistillate astatine gunpoint and fired upon witnesses who pursued him. They accidental a loaded .38 caliber revolver was recovered from nether the driver’s spot of Young’s car.
—Samuel Herrera Jr.: Herrera was changeable and killed Sept. 10, 2020, by deputies successful the 500 artifact of South Bradfield Avenue successful Compton, according to instrumentality enforcement and region coroner’s records.
Detectives from the Sheriff’s Department’s Operation Safe Streets Bureau were serving a hunt warrant erstwhile they said Herrera “opened fire,” according to a section report. The section said Samuel Herrera Jr. fled from a location into a detached garage. Deputies fired 15 rounds aft they said Herrera fired astatine them portion “barricaded” successful the garage.
Deputies fired again when, they said, Herrera “broke through” a broadside partition of the garage. Herrera was pronounced dormant astatine the country and a limb was recovered, deputies said.
–Dijon Kizzee: Kizzee was changeable Aug. 31, 2020 by 2 sheriff’s deputies successful the unincorporated assemblage of Westmont, adjacent South Los Angeles.
Deputies said they initially stopped Kizzee for riding a motorcycle connected the incorrect broadside of East 110th Street.
Sheriff’s Homicide Bureau Capt. Kent Wegener said Kizzee was carrying a loaded handgun. He dropped it during the archetypal confrontation and carnal altercation, but picked it up from the crushed and pointed it toward the deputies, prompting the shooting, Wegener said.
Attorneys for the household of the 29-year-old Kizzee announced a $35 cardinal damages assertion against the region successful February.
County Coroner Dr. Jonathan Lucas has already ruled each decease a homicide and successful each 3 cases determined that the origin of decease was gunshot wounds.
Lucas told the committee successful January that inquests are an enquiry into the circumstances, mode and origin of decease and not meant to settee ineligible issues.
“It’s not a trial, it is not an adversarial process … determination is nary guilt oregon innocence that comes retired of an inquest … it is not a quest to find each of the circumstances,” the coroner said astatine the time
COC Commissioner Priscilla Ocen said successful January that it was important for the nationalist to spot that the region is taking these investigations seriously.
The committee Tuesday directed the coroner to enactment with region counsel, the inspector wide and COC to make a wide argumentation connected inquests successful deaths related to lawman shootings.
Lucas said successful January that it would beryllium hard to enforce a argumentation that was thing different than “all oregon none.” He besides raised concerns astir costs and constricted resources, though helium acknowledged these should not beryllium paramount.
Supervisor Sheila Kuehl offered a “friendly amendment” Tuesday calling for the CEO and different staffers to fund the costs and spot if caller backing sources could beryllium identified. That amendment was accepted and approved.
City News Service contributed to this report.
English (US) ·