Lawyer: Case against Smollett based on testimony of ‘liars’

By DON BABWIN and SARA BURNETT

CHICAGO (AP) — Jussie Smollett’s defence lawyer told jurors Wednesday that charges the erstwhile “Empire” histrion faked an anti-gay, racist onslaught connected himself and lied to constabulary astir it trust connected the grounds of brothers who are “sophisticated liars” and “the worst benignant of criminals.”

Attorney Nenye Uche said successful his closing statement that during grounds past week successful the Chicago courtroom, 1 of the brothers “said ‘I don’t recall’ truthful galore times, it is ridiculous.”

“The full prosecution’s case, including the instauration of the case, is built similar a location of cards,” Uche said.

Special authoritative Dan Webb told the assemblage earlier Wednesday that the grounds against Smollett is “overwhelming,” and that what helium did successful January 2019 caused Chicago constabulary to walk tremendous amounts of clip and resources investigating an alleged transgression that turned retired to beryllium fake. Smollett, who is Black and gay, told constabulary idiosyncratic enactment a noose astir his cervix and yelled racist and homophobic slurs.

“Besides being against the law, it is conscionable plain incorrect to outright denigrate thing arsenic superior arsenic a existent hatred transgression and past marque definite it progressive words and symbols that person specified humanities value successful our country,” Webb said.

He besides accused Smollett of lying to jurors, saying surveillance video from earlier the alleged onslaught and that nighttime contradicts cardinal moments of Smollett’s testimony.

“At the extremity of the day, helium lacks immoderate credibility whatsoever,” Webb said.

The assemblage successful Smollett’s proceedings is expected to statesman deliberating aboriginal Wednesday whether Smollett is blameworthy connected six counts of a low-level felony for making what prosecutors accidental was a mendacious constabulary study astir the alleged attack. He faces 1 number of felony disorderly behaviour for each clip helium gave a study to 3 antithetic officers.

Taking the witnesser basal this week, Smollett repeatedly denied the onslaught was a fake, telling a authoritative “there was nary hoax connected my part” and that 2 brothers who testified against him are “liars.”

Smollett called the Osundairo brothers’ grounds that helium paid them $3,500 to transportation retired the fake onslaught “100% false,” and described however helium was the unfortunate of a hatred transgression portion walking successful his vicinity aboriginal connected Jan. 29, 2019. He besides testified that a $3,500 cheque helium wrote for Abimbola Osundairo was for repast and workout plans due to the fact that helium was trying to get toned for an upcoming euphony video.

Smollett testified that helium was returning location from buying a sandwich astir 2 a.m. erstwhile idiosyncratic yelled a racist, homophobic remark that referenced the TV amusement “Empire.” The idiosyncratic besides shouted thing astir “MAGA country,” an evident notation to then-President Donald Trump’s slogan “Make America Great Again.” The slogan besides had been scrawled connected immoderate hatred mail, featuring a drafting of a instrumentality fig hanging by a noose, that Smollett had received astatine the “Empire” set, helium testified.

Smollett said erstwhile helium turned to face the person, a antheral deed him successful the caput and helium fell to the ground, wherever helium said different antheral kicked him earlier the attackers ran away. Smollett said helium noticed a rope, similar a noose, astir his cervix aft the attack. When helium returned home, a person called Chicago police, thing Smollett said helium wouldn’t person done due to the fact that arsenic a Black antheral helium doesn’t spot police.

Uche told the assemblage that 1 of the brothers, Olabingo Osundairo, is homophobic, noting helium posted homophobic slurs connected societal media. Uche suggested that was the motive for their attack.

“Why is that important? Because Jussie is openly gay,” Uche said.

Webb said during Wednesday’s closing arguments that Smollett lied erstwhile helium testified that helium picked up the Osundairo brothers a fewer days earlier the alleged onslaught truthful they could enactment out, alternatively than to bash a “dry run” of the fake attack, arsenic the brothers told jurors past week. In surveillance video, the men are seen driving astir Smollett’s flat gathering 3 times, but Smollett ne'er parked his car to spell workout.

The brothers testified that Smollett pointed retired a surveillance camera adjacent the intersection that would grounds the fake attack, truthful it could beryllium publicized connected societal media. But Smollett testified Tuesday that it wasn’t antithetic for him to thrust astir successful circles, and that helium canceled the program to enactment retired due to the fact that helium didn’t privation to enactment retired with Olabingo Osundairo, whom helium hadn’t invited along.

During his closing argument, Uche told jurors that Smollett often drove astir smoking marijuana and making music, and helium questioned wherefore prosecutors didn’t get surveillance video of him doing so.

“They don’t privation to bash it due to the fact that it would amusement you it wasn’t a adust run,” Uche said.

The brothers besides said Smollett gave them $100 to bargain supplies for the attack, including a enactment to manner into a noose. Surveillance video from wrong and extracurricular Chicago businesses captured the men buying the items, Webb noted.

Webb besides referenced surveillance video that shows the Osundairo brothers — who are Black — walking astir the country the nighttime of the alleged attack. Webb questioned however the brothers — who didn’t unrecorded adjacent — would cognize to beryllium successful the country astir 2 a.m. during freezing acold upwind for the fake attack.

“They knew wherever helium was going to beryllium due to the fact that Smollett told them wherever helium was going to be,” Webb said.

But Uche said the brothers testified they arrived 40 minutes early, adding “they were casing him.”

During his cross-examination of Smollett connected Tuesday, Webb presented backstage messages Smollett sent to Abimbola Osundairo earlier successful the evening of the alleged assault, erstwhile Smollett’s formation location to Chicago was delayed. A connection astir 90 minutes earlier the alleged battle indicated helium had arrived successful Chicago. Smollett archetypal denied helium sent the messages, but acknowledged them aft Webb showed that helium had. Smollett said helium was arranging a workout.

Webb besides questioned wherefore Smollett didn’t crook implicit his cellphone to constabulary oregon springiness them a DNA illustration oregon entree to his aesculapian records to assistance with the investigation. Smollett testified helium doesn’t spot Chicago police, and that helium was acrophobic astir his privacy.

“If helium was a existent unfortunate of a transgression helium would not beryllium withholding evidence,” Webb said. “Mr. Smollett didn’t privation the transgression solved. … He didn’t privation the brothers apprehended.”

Uche called it “nonsense” for Chicago constabulary to inquire Smollett for his DNA erstwhile helium was inactive considered a unfortunate of a crime. He noted Smollett aboriginal provided DNA to the FBI for a abstracted probe into hatred message helium had received astatine the “Empire” workplace soon earlier the alleged attack.

“He wasn’t hiding anything,” Uche said.

The disorderly behaviour complaint is simply a people 4 felony that carries a situation condemnation of up to 3 years, but experts person said if Smollett is convicted, helium would apt beryllium placed connected probation and ordered to execute assemblage service.

___

Check retired the AP’s implicit sum of the Jussie Smollett case.